Main shelf was split and bowed, stapled battens needed re-positioning and reinforcing, pre-drilled screw holes not in the right place, hinges attached to wrong piece (made identifying the correct position difficult). Wood very lightweight and easily split when screwed, whole item did not assemble as a true rectangle. Very flimsy. While I appreciate the partial refund for the broken shelf I still do not consider this value for money. I suggest the seller tries to assemble one as per the instructions!