The only way this isn't 5 stars is Series 1 and 2 looked like they'd been used ever so slightly. One or two tiny scratch like markings that won't interfere with playback. Finger prints on the occasional disc. And one or two smear markings. Yes this can mostly be cleaned up. But the box set is supposed to be NEW for goodness sake. And it was sealed when it arrived. So it must be a case of poor packing of the discs from the distributor.